Resolving Business Valuation Disputes in New York and New Jersey
When business partners in New York or New Jersey can’t work together anymore, the hardest part often isn’t agreeing on a buyout. It’s deciding what the business is worth. Valuation fights are one of the biggest roadblocks in what’s often called a business divorce.
Without clear valuation rules in a shareholder agreement, operating agreement, or partnership agreement, owners can end up stuck in costly litigation. Even when both sides agree that one partner should leave, disputes over price remain. The exiting partner wants fair value for their contribution, while the remaining partner wants to avoid financial strain as they continue the business without support.
Why Valuation Disputes Happen
Valuation fights are rarely just about numbers. They usually grow out of a breakdown in the relationship. Partnership disputes often involve:
- Concerns about how the company is managed,
- Unequal contributions of time or effort, or
- Claims that one owner benefits more than the other.
By the time a buyout is on the table, trust is gone. Partners may agree in principle that a buyout should happen so they can go their separate ways, but not on the value. That disagreement can stall the process and push everyone into expensive litigation.
Example: Two 50/50 owners of a New Jersey company hit a deadlock. One wants to exit. Each hires their own appraiser. The valuations don’t match, and the fight ends up in court. The process drags on, drains money, and keeps both owners from moving forward.
Common Valuation Mechanisms
Strong governance documents — shareholder agreements, operating agreements, and partnership agreements — should spell out how the business will be valued. Some options include:
- Fixed Formula – book value, an EBITDA multiple, or another set calculation.
- Independent Appraisal – an outside expert sets fair market value. A “dueling appraiser” clause can allow a neutral third appraiser to break ties.
- Agreed-Upon Accountant – partners designate a trusted accountant in advance.
- Market Comparables – using recent sales of similar businesses.
- Regular Valuations – requiring annual valuations to avoid surprises.
The right method depends on the type of business, its growth plans, and the level of trust between the owners.
Benefits of Clear Valuation Language
Valuation provisions in governance documents provide:
- Clarity – everyone knows the process in advance.
- Fairness – no self-serving estimates.
- Fewer Lawsuits – less risk of valuation battles in court.
Avoiding the Hassle
Business partner disputes are stressful enough. Don’t add years of courtroom battles over valuation.
The smart move is to include valuation rules in your operating agreement or shareholder agreement at the outset. If you skipped this step, it’s not too late. Agreements can be amended to add buyout and valuation terms. Doing so now can save time, money, and stress later.
We’ve seen countless clients avoid the cost of drafting a tailored agreement. Some relied on a boilerplate ones that ignored valuation. They ended up wishing they hadn’t.
Take Action Now
If you are a New York or New Jersey business owner facing a partnership dispute, or if you want to update your governance documents to prevent future problems, now is the time to act. A clear valuation mechanism is one of the best protections against a painful and expensive business divorce.
Disclaimer
This corporate lawyer blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It is not an offer for Russo Law LLC to represent any party, nor does it create an attorney-client relationship. No action or inaction should be taken based on the information provided without seeking professional legal counsel. This post is intended for businesses in New York and New Jersey. It may not reflect laws in other jurisdictions.
This blog post is attorney advertising. While efforts are made to ensure the accuracy and usefulness of the information, Russo Law LLC makes no representations, warranties, or guarantees, express or implied. This includes no guarantees about its accuracy, completeness, or applicability. It also encompasses any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. Laws and regulations change often. Russo Law LLC is not responsible for updating this blog post to show subsequent legal developments.
Russo Law LLC assumes no legal liability or responsibility for the use of any information, materials, products, or processes mentioned in this post. It does not guarantee that reliance on this information will result in any particular outcome. Prior results do not guarantee a similar result. Links to third-party websites are provided for convenience only. Russo Law LLC does not endorse or assume responsibility for the accuracy or content of external sources.
Do not send confidential or sensitive information through this website or in response to this blog post. Unsolicited information does not create an attorney-client relationship and should not be treated as privileged or confidential.