My Co-Owner Died — Now I’m in Business With Their Spouse. What Are My Options?

One of the situations that business succession planning is specifically designed to prevent is finding yourself in business with someone you never chose as a partner. When a co-owner dies without a buy-sell agreement in place, their ownership interest typically passes to their estate and then — through a will or intestacy — to their heirs. Often, that means the surviving spouse. This post describes what typically happens in that situation and what options the surviving business owner may have.

What Rights Does the Inheriting Spouse Have?

The rights of a person who inherits a business interest depend on the entity type, the governing documents, and the applicable state law. In an LLC, the transfer of a membership interest to an heir may not automatically admit that person as a full member with management and voting rights. Under New York LLC law, a transferee who is not admitted as a member by the remaining members may be entitled to distributions and economic rights but not to management rights.

However, the operating agreement may provide otherwise — and many basic or template operating agreements are silent on what happens upon the death of a member, which can create ambiguity about what rights the inheriting spouse actually has. In partnerships, the default rules are different and may give heirs more immediate rights depending on the governing documents and applicable statute.

The Operating Agreement Governs

The starting point is the operating agreement or partnership agreement. Does it contain a buy-sell provision that obligates the surviving owners — or the business — to purchase the deceased owner’s interest? Does it restrict transfers to non-members? Does it require the consent of remaining members before an heir can be admitted? These provisions, if they exist, determine the framework for addressing the situation.

If the operating agreement is silent or does not contain workable buy-sell provisions, the surviving owner’s options narrow considerably.

Negotiating a Buyout

Even without a contractual obligation, it is often possible to negotiate a buyout of the inherited interest with the estate or the surviving spouse. The key issues are valuation — what the interest is worth — and terms of payment. The surviving spouse may have no interest in or ability to participate in the business and may be motivated to achieve liquidity. Or they may have expectations about the value of the interest that differ significantly from what the surviving owner believes is fair.

If the parties cannot agree on value, they may need to engage appraisers or, in some cases, litigate the valuation question. A business attorney can help structure the buyout negotiation and the resulting transaction.

The Better Answer Is Planning Ahead

The situation described in this post — involuntary co-ownership with a deceased partner’s heir — is precisely what a well-drafted buy-sell agreement is designed to prevent. A buy-sell agreement that addresses the death of an owner, establishes a valuation mechanism, and ideally is funded with life insurance gives the surviving owner a clear, pre-agreed path to acquiring the deceased owner’s interest without negotiation or litigation at the worst possible moment.

Business owners who are concerned about this scenario should consult with a business attorney to evaluate their current governing documents and what planning steps are appropriate for their situation. For related topics, see our page on succession planning and our post on buy-sell agreements.

Business owners concerned about this scenario are welcome to schedule a consultation with Russo Law LLC to evaluate their current governing documents and what planning steps are appropriate.


Disclaimer

The legal and business issues discussed in this post vary depending on the specific facts and circumstances of each situation. The legal and business issues discussed in this post vary depending on the specific facts and circumstances of each situation. This corporate lawyer blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It is not an offer for Russo Law LLC to represent any party, nor does it create an attorney-client relationship. No action or inaction should be taken based on the information provided without seeking professional legal counsel. This post is intended for businesses in New York and New Jersey. It may not reflect laws in other jurisdictions.

Do not send confidential or sensitive information through this website or in response to this blog post. Unsolicited information does not create an attorney-client relationship and should not be treated as privileged or confidential.

Leave a Comment