What Is an Indemnification Clause and Why Does Everyone Fight Over It?
If you have ever been involved in negotiating a business contract, you have probably noticed that indemnification provisions generate more back-and-forth than almost any other clause. That is not a coincidence. Indemnification provisions determine who bears the financial consequences if something goes wrong — and in a business deal, the potential consequences can be significant. Understanding what an indemnification clause does, and why the specific language matters, is important for any business owner entering into a significant contract.
What Indemnification Means
To indemnify means to compensate someone for a loss or liability. In a contract, an indemnification provision obligates one party — the indemnifying party — to cover the losses, costs, or liabilities of the other party — the indemnified party — if certain specified events occur. In a business acquisition, for example, the seller typically indemnifies the buyer for losses arising from a breach of the seller’s representations and warranties in the purchase agreement. In a commercial contract, one party may indemnify the other for claims arising from its own negligence or misconduct.
What Indemnification Provisions Cover
The scope of an indemnification obligation is defined by what losses are covered. A broad indemnification provision may cover losses, damages, liabilities, costs, expenses, judgments, settlements, and legal fees. A narrower one may cover only direct damages, excluding consequential or indirect losses. The categories of covered losses are heavily negotiated, particularly in business acquisitions where the potential indemnification exposure can be large.
Caps, Baskets, and Deductibles
Three structural concepts limit indemnification exposure in business deals: caps, baskets, and deductibles.
A cap is a ceiling on the indemnifying party’s total liability. In an acquisition, the cap is often expressed as a percentage of the purchase price — commonly somewhere between ten and one hundred percent depending on the deal and what is being indemnified. Fundamental representations — such as title to the business and authority to enter the deal — are often carved out from the cap entirely.
A basket is a threshold below which claims are not indemnifiable. A “tipping basket” means that once claims exceed the threshold, the full amount of all claims is recoverable. A “deductible basket” means that only the amount above the threshold is recoverable. The distinction matters considerably when actual claims arise.
Mutual vs. One-Sided Indemnification
Indemnification can run in one direction or both. In many commercial contracts, a more powerful party will propose a one-sided indemnification that requires the other party to indemnify it but not vice versa. Negotiating mutual indemnification — so that each party bears the consequences of its own conduct — is one of the first issues that practitioners address in reviewing a draft agreement.
Legal Fees
Whether indemnification covers the indemnified party’s legal fees in defending a covered claim — and under what conditions — is often a significant practical issue. An indemnification that covers losses but not the cost of the litigation needed to establish those losses provides less protection than it appears to on its face.
Business owners reviewing or negotiating indemnification provisions should work with a business attorney to understand the scope of protection they are receiving and the exposure they are taking on. For related topics, see our pages on business contracts and limitation of liability clauses.
Business owners reviewing or negotiating indemnification provisions are welcome to schedule a consultation with Russo Law LLC to understand the scope of protection they are receiving and the exposure they are taking on.
Disclaimer
The legal and business issues discussed in this post vary depending on the specific facts and circumstances of each situation. The legal and business issues discussed in this post vary depending on the specific facts and circumstances of each situation. This corporate lawyer blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It is not an offer for Russo Law LLC to represent any party, nor does it create an attorney-client relationship. No action or inaction should be taken based on the information provided without seeking professional legal counsel. This post is intended for businesses in New York and New Jersey. It may not reflect laws in other jurisdictions.
Do not send confidential or sensitive information through this website or in response to this blog post. Unsolicited information does not create an attorney-client relationship and should not be treated as privileged or confidential.